A Recipe from 100 Prize-Winning Grand National Recipes from Pillsbury’s 6th Grand National $100,000 Recipe and Baking Contest (1955)

About the Recipe

I had intended to have these cookies as a fun treat with Maxx, but then everyone started trying them. And wow are they delicious. The butter cookie melts in your mouth and is complemented so perfectly by the brown butter frosting.

A few quick notes and tips on these:

• After the initial flour amount, I added about a tablespoon at a time until I got to the dough consistency, and then I refrigerated for a solid 3 hours before actually trying to use the dough, which made it much easier to handle.
• After the first batch of tiny, marble-shaped cookies I got a little bored and decided to make bigger ones, about the size of a cherry to start before you smoosh them. I think those worked just as well, and if you’re not sad about cutting the quantity down are certainly a way to make it go faster.
• My oven runs a little bit cold, but I found these needed a solid 13-14 minutes in the oven, even at the smaller size.
• Let the cookies cool before you try to frost them. This should be a given, but I tried to do some too soon and they just crumbled in my hand.

Other than that, these are perfect, just the way they are. Thanks a bunch to Helen Beckman of Mt. Vernon, Iowa for this snappy prize-winning recipe.

About the book

Out of all of my Pillsbury books, I think this might be the one I’ve cooked out of the most. There are some good, not too complicated recipes, and we haven’t yet entered the era of pre-made dough or mixes. For more Pillsbury, click the tag, or check out the Pillsbury Challenge that I did during the pandemic.

The Recipe!

Ingredients:

1 cup butter or margarine
3/4 cup firmly packed brown sugar
1 unbeaten egg yolk
2 1/4 cups sifted flour

Browned Butter Frosting:
2 T butter or margarine
1 1/4 cups sifted confectioners’ sugar
1/2 t vanilla extract
4-5 t cream

Directions:

Cream butter or margarine. Gradually add brown sugar, creaming well. Blend in egg yolk, then add flour. Stir until mixture forms a dough. Chill if necessary for handling.

Shape into balls about the size of a marble. Place on ungreased baking sheet and flatten to a 1/8″ thickness with the palm of the hand. Mark a design by pressing with fork in one direction.

Bake in slow oven (325*F) 8-10 minutes until cookies begin to brown very lightly. Remove from sheets while warm. Place flat sides of two cookies together with frosting, sandwich-style. Cookies are also delicious plain.

Browned Butter Frosting:
Brown slightly butter or margarine in saucepan. Remove from heat and blend in confectioners’ sugar. Gradually add vanilla and cream until of spreading consistency.